Why did my honey bees die?

 

Learning to identify a common cause of winter death in Northern Climates

By Meghan Milbrath, Michigan State University Extension, March 8, 2016

Guest Blog

Beekeepers in northern climates have already lost a lot of colonies this winter.  While official counts won’t be recorded for a few months, some trends are starting to emerge.  One of these trends is a specific type of colony death.  In Michigan, I’ve received so many calls describing the scenario below, that I can describe the deadout before opening the hive, or before the beekeeper describes it over the phone.  While I may impress some with these predictive powers, the frequency of these types of losses indicates a real epidemic that is affecting honey bee colonies in northern states.

Characteristics of the common early winter death in northern states:

  1. The colony was big and looked healthy in the fall
  2. A lot of honey is left in the top supers
  3. The cluster is now small, maybe the size of a softball
  4. There are hardly any bees on the bottom board
  5. Near or just below the cluster is a patch of spotty brood – some fully capped, and some with bees dying on emergence (heads facing out, tongues sticking out).
  6. If you look closely in the cells around the brood, you will see white crystals stuck to the cell walls, looking like someone sprinkled coarse salt in the brood nest.

AND

  1. You don’t have records showing that varroa was under control.

Sound familiar?

We see this classic set of symptoms over and over in the states with a proper winter.   A big colony that seems to just shrink down and disappear.  Many people want to use the term colony collapse for this type of death, and while collapse is a good descriptor of what happens, this is not true colony collapse disorder.   This is death by varroa associated viruses.

How does it happen?

  1. The big colonies –While beekeepers are often surprised that their big colonies are the ones that are gone first, it makes perfect sense in terms of varroa growth.  Since varroa mites reproduce in capped brood, the colonies that made the most brood (i.e. got the biggest) are the ones most at risk of having a high population of varroa.  Colonies that swarmed, or didn’t take off, or even fought a disease like chalk brood are less at risk from high varroa populations, because they didn’t consistently have large amounts    You should have good notes indicating cluster size going into winter, but even if you don’t, you can see the large circle of food eaten by a large cluster.

 

Frame

This colony had a large brood nest (indicated by the dark comb in this frame from the top deep box), and a large cluster going into winter (indicated by the large amount of honey that is eaten away where the winter cluster started).  Varroa were never monitored or managed in this colony, and it was dead by February, if not sooner. (Photo by Meghan Milbrath)

  1. Lots of Honey – Lots of honey means that the colony died fairly early. Colonies with high levels of varroa, they tend to die fairly early in the season (before February), leaving lots of honey behind.  Once the bees are stressed and in cluster, the viruses take their toll very quickly.  In some cases the colony will even abscond in fall, or be dead before winter really hits.

The colony shown above had a third deep box that was filled with capped honey, indicating that the bees died early, and starvation was not the culprit.

  1. Small cluster – Varroa levels peak right when the winter bees are getting formed. The bees that emerge from varroa infested cells are weakened, and more importantly, are riddled with viruses.  Varroa mites are notorious for carrying deformed wing viruses (DWV), but are known to transmit many more.  When bees are close tight in a winter cluster, the viruses can spread very quickly.

In our colony, the cluster was only the size of our hand – some bees had their heads stuck in the cells, trying to stay warm, others had fallen between the frames.

  1. No bees on the bottom board – When a colony starves, the bees just drop to the bottom board, and you end up with a pile of dead bees in the hive. When bees get sick with viruses and other pathogens, however, they often will fly away.   Sick bees by nature leave the colony to die in the field, an act designed to prevent pathogen transmission in the colony.  When most bees are sick, they either fly away, or are too weak to return after cleansing flights.  An early fall illness means that a lot of the bodies probably got removed by workers too.

The colony we examined had only a few bees left on the bottom board (1-2 cups).   We didn’t see a lot of varroa, but there had been some robbing, so wax cappings covered a lot of the board.

  1. Patch of spotty brood/ Bees dying on emergence – When a colony succumbs to varroa associated viruses or parasitic mite syndrome (PMS), we see a lot of effects in the brood. Unlike American Foulbrood (AFB), which attacks the larvae at one particular stage, PMS will affect developing bees at many stages of development.  It is one of the only diseases where you see bees dying right as they emerge.

Photo 2Note the bee in the upper left is fully formed, and died on emergence.  You can often see frozen/melted larvae along with dead pupae.  Many beekeepers instantly suspect AFB, but AFB infected colonies usually will not be large and have produced a lot of honey going into the winter. (Photo by Meghan Milbrath)

  1. White crystals in the brood – Around the cells where the brood died (the last place of the brood nest), you will often see white crystals stuck to the walls of the cells. These are dry (not suspended in liquid like crystalized honey), and are the crystalized pee of varroa.   Varroa mites defecate in the cells, and the resulting guanine crystals are left behind, and visible to the naked eye.

Photo 3Cells on the left side of this photo contain small crystals of guanine acid, indicating varroa defecation.   Notice the dry, irregular shape, and that they appear stuck to the walls on the cells.  Some cells on the right side of this photo contain crystallized sugar.  Note the wet/liquid appearance, and that it is largely in the bottom of the cell. (Photo by Meghan Milbrath)

  1. No records that varroa was under control. Notice that this says ‘varroa was under control’, and not that ‘the colony was treated’.  You may have applied a treatment, but it may have been too little, or (more likely) too late.  This year was a particularly difficult year for this, because in Michigan we had a really late summer – it stayed warm enough for beekeepers to go into their hives well into October.   Many beekeepers took the extra time to put on a varroa treatment, thinking that they were lucky to get one in.  While that treatment could help the bees for next season, it was too late for this winter.  September and October treatments would have been applied after varroa had gotten to their winter bees.  Winter bees are born in the fall, and with their special fat deposits that allow them to live through the winter months, they are the one who carry the colony to the next season.  If the winter bees have already been infected with viruses, the damage is done.  No amount of treatment or varroa drop would bring the colony back.

The only way to know that you have varroa under control is to monitor using a sugar roll or an alcohol wash.  Just looking at the bees does not work; varroa mites are so sneaky, that you rarely ever see them, unless the infestation is out of control, and it is too late.   Many beekeepers say that they never see varroa in their hives, so they don’t think that they have a problem.   In fact, a varroa infested hive can actually look like it is thriving.   Underneath the lovely brood cappings, and away from our view, the mites are reproducing and biting the developing bees.  The colony can look fairly healthy until the mites reach a threshold, and the colony succumbs to disease.  By the time you see parasitic mite syndrome, or see varroa crawling on bees, it is often too late for that colony (especially if winter is just around the corner).   Getting on a schedule of monitoring and managing mites will give you peace of mind that your healthy looking colony is indeed healthy.

The silver lining

If the above scenario is familiar, don’t despair.   First, you are not alone.  Many beekeepers got caught off guard with varroa this year.  They didn’t realize how bad it was, or got thrown off by odd weather patterns.  Second, when the bees die, the varroa mites die too.   We don’t yet have evidence that the viruses would stay in the equipment, so you can reuse your old frames.  The honey that is left can be extracted to enjoy (if you didn’t feed or medicate), and frames of drawn comb can be given to new colonies.   Most importantly, if you recognize the above scenario in your colonies, you now have more knowledge as to what is harming your bees, and you can take positive action.   You have time for this season to develop a strategy. Monitor your varroa mite levels using a sugar roll kit (available at pollinators.msu.edu/mite-check/ or at Mann Lake), read about integrated pest management for varroa, and make a commitment to prevent high mite levels this year before your winter bees are developing.   This is going to be the year!

Meghan Milbrath, Ph.D.

 

mpi@msu.edu /517-884-9518

Meghan Milbrath is a beekeeper and the coordinator of the Michigan Pollinator Initiative at Michigan State University.   She performs pollinator related research and extension work, and works with beekeepers and stakeholders around the country. She started keeping bees over 20 years ago, and currently owns and manages a The Sand Hill apiaries, where she manages 150-200 colonies for queen rearing and nuc production.

BioPhoto_AndrewPotter Photo 4

Written By: Meghan Milbrath

Meghan Milbrath has written 1 post in this blog.

Meghan Milbrath is a beekeeper and the coordinator of the Michigan Pollinator Initiative at Michigan State University. She performs pollinator related research and extension work, and works with beekeepers and stakeholders around the country. She started keeping bees over 20 years ago, and currently owns and manages a The Sand Hill apiaries, where she manages 150-200 colonies for queen rearing and nuc production.

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail
  • louis daher

    Thanks Megan and Karen!

  • Ericka

    So very helpful. I needed this!!

  • don coats

    These are very helpful details. We might also benefit from a suggested seasonal threshold discussion along with recommended treatment options. does drone comb removal really help?

  • Terry Whittam

    Thanks Meghan and Karen,
    Our hives are still snow covered here in central Ontario. I’ll be opening in the next month and I appreciate this information and checklist of things to look for. Thank you, Terry Whittam Washago, Ontario, Canada

  • Pingback: Why Did My Honey Bees Die? | Bee Champions()

  • Tal

    Thank you for the great info!

    A question:
    You attribute these type of losses to varroa destructor vectored virus (or viruses). How do you differentiate these type of losses as opposed to nosema-affected colony (either nosema apis or nosema ceranae)?

  • J. Boyne

    This was an excellent article and ought to be required reading (especially for hobby beekeepers). Very useful information!

  • Lewis Cauble

    Meghan,
    Please check the text description of the picture in part 6. It looks to me that the quanine acid is on the left side of the picture instead of on the right as indicated in the text. Am I looking at it wrong? I want to share this article with many people but I want to make sure it is accurate. Can you double check for me? Thank you.

    • Meghan Milbrath

      The photo was flipped when it was uploaded. Should be correct now. Thanks for catching that!

  • Mike

    In England a lot of bee keepers use a mesh floor in the hive where varroa mites fall through onto a solid floor and are unable to get back into the brood chamber.
    In this way a beekeeper can monitor the scale of any infestation. Do you have this hive set up in the USA?

    • Mark Hanson

      yes. I switched to mesh floors about 15 years ago.

    • Queenbee

      We use screen bottom boards (SBB) extensively for both mite monitoring and mite control
      I’m sure it’s very similar to your mesh floor

  • Kelly Hoyt

    very helpful! I am copying as we speak to add to My Beekeepers Bible!

  • Jenn

    Excellent description. I’ll be sharing with my bee club! Curious what dead bees with heads stuck in comb means? Still lots of honey, some clustered, but lots of dead bees head first in the comb? Thoughts?

  • Pingback: Resource Page – NewBees: Beginning Beekeeping()

  • John

    “The only way to know that you have varroa under control is to monitor
    using a sugar roll or an alcohol wash. Just looking at the bees does
    not work” …. Eh ??

    Have you Beekeepers in the ‘States’ never heard of a Varroa floor to monitor mite drop and treat accordingly … shame on you ?

  • Rusty

    Thanks. I am looking for all the up to date, old and in between literature I can find before I start my first hives. Until two months ago I didn’t know what a hive looked like inside.

  • Afonso

    Thanks!

  • Pingback: Why Did My Honey Bees Die? | Bee Informed Partnership | Omaha Bee Club()

  • L Binner

    New to bee keeping. I’m going on my third year and experienced what happened above all most to the letter!! This was one of the best reads yet!!!

  • Don Rota

    This article was highly recommended by my instructor (Who’s the president of the Massachusetts Bee Keepers Association. http://www.massbee.org/). He also recommended that when you do a sugar roll test, if you have 6% mites ( 12 mites per 1/3 mason jar of bees ~= 200 bees ) is probably a “death’s-door point” – where the colony might be beyond a saving point, unless you do something drastic.) He recommends ‘the organic’ treatments of Formic acid, or Oxalic acid, or Thymol monthly to knock down the count all year long – (and never using the last two treatments when honey supers are on.). Can you point me at any other studies that show how effective these are (or other organic treatments?) Lastly, how well do these hold up (actual test statistics) in relation to other IPMs, like screen bottom boards, drone comb removal, and dusting hives with powered sugar? Great work! on your article – ya I just bought my first hive today – Bees come next month. Looking forward to the challenge.

  • Pingback: Why did my honey bees die? - American Honey Producers()

  • Pingback: Spring preparations for the season. – Sky Barn Apiaries()

  • Pingback: Of Mice and Bees – My Adventures in Beekeeping()

  • Pingback: Why Did My Bees Die? – NWDBA()

  • eyeman

    Excellent article Meghan.
    I came across ‘spring dwindling’ in 3 colonies this year.
    This colony had less than a handful of bees with their queen (Pic1) . If I had left them another week or two the hive would be empty.
    In this situation it may still be possible to save the queen. Can I suggest
    1. You make up a mini mating nucleus with young bees from a health colony (Another reason to always have 2 or more colonies) as per the mini nuc’s instructions, supplying them with fondant.
    2. Leave alone for 2+ hours so they recognise they are queenless.
    3. Take your queen from the dwindling colony and put her in a queen cage.
    4. Put the queen cage next to the ventilation screen of the mini nuc for 1-2 hours so they get used to her scent (Pic2).
    5. The bees should now be relaxed, calm and quiet. The queen can be directly inserted into the mini nuc.
    6. Keep the mini nuc in a cool place for 4 days, spraying with water once a day.
    7. Move the mini nuc outside in the late evening and open the entrance.
    8. Check 1 week later and if your lucky the queen will be laying and thriving (Pic 3).

  • Pingback: June program by WNC Bee Inspector Lewis Cauble on Controlling Varroa Mites | Transylvania Beekeeping Club()

  • Pingback: Bees in the Time of Varroa | The Prospect of Bees()

  • Pingback: GloryBee | The Three most important words beekeepers should know / Glorybee()

  • Pingback: PWRBA with special guest Dr. Meghan Milbrath- Tue. Oct. 18th at 7 pm()

  • Pingback: GloryBee | How to Winterize your Hives [Part 3] / Glorybee()

  • Jitka Adeleke

    Thanks for this article, it seems that this exactly happened to me now during Sept/October, the whole hive gone including the queen, just 4 cups of bees left. The only difference is that I also see hundreds of dead and dying bees crawling around the hive. Do you think it would still make sense to add one or two frames of brood from another hive to help them raise a queen, or is it too late?

  • Pingback: CSI: Forensics in Fife - The Apiarist()

  • matthew hogan

    we have treated for mites. today we found pupa bees outside the hive along with some bees that had their wings damaged. any ideas what is going on?

  • Victoria

    I live 10 miles south of Ludington, MI.This morning while walking on the beach between Pentwater and Ludington, I noticed literally hundreds of bees acting in a dazed and bizarre fashion. They were unable to fly, were walking into Lake MI, or would roll over and seem unable to right themselves.It was horrible to see this.
    We have many apple orchards around us and I did notice some spraying of a powder-like substance on Misenheimer Road. I am also aware of a zombie fly that can infect the brains of bees and cause behavior similar to what I observed today.
    I just wanted to notify someone of this and did not know if there is a particular organization which I should contact?
    Thank you!